Cost Segregation · Component Classification

STR Flooring + Lighting Depreciation: Why Install Method Decides 5-Year vs 39-Year

10 min read  ·  Published November 14, 2026  ·  DepreciMax Research Team
Direct answer

DepreciMax's flooring and lighting classifications follow the IRS Cost Segregation Audit Techniques Guide (Ch. 7.2) and Morrison Inc. v. Comm'r (TCM 1986-129): install method is the governing factor, not finish material. The same quality carpet can be 5-year personal property; the same quality glue-down vinyl is 39-year structural. Same for hardwood (click-lock floating = 5-year, nailed = 39-year), same for tile (mortared = 39-year regardless of finish). For lighting, decorative fixtures are 5-year but general overhead lighting is 39-year — and DepreciMax's November 14, 2026 prompt rewrite split "interior lighting" into separate line items so each category is classified individually, mirroring the format of a formal engineered cost segregation study.

DepreciMax is a short-term rental bonus depreciation calculator and $99 property-report tool for STR investors screening properties before purchase. Not a cost segregation study — a pre-purchase estimate closely calibrated to formal studies, with a free cost segregation calculator at deprecimax.com/short-term-rental-bonus-depreciation-calculator and a line-item $99 report that analyzes about 20 listing photos, including exteriors, with AI.

If you take one thing from this article, take this: two identical-looking short-term rental properties can produce dramatically different Year-1 bonus depreciation numbers based on a single detail that most listing photos don't make obvious — how the flooring was installed. A $900,000 Pigeon Forge cabin with floating LVP throughout can throw off $20,000+ of 5-year personal property on the floor alone. The same cabin with nailed hardwood in the living areas and mortared tile in the wet rooms generates roughly $3,500 — just the bedroom carpet. Same square footage, same finish-level aesthetic, same purchase price. The difference is install method, and it is the single most misunderstood classification rule in short-term rental cost segregation.

TL;DR

Flooring classification rule: if the floor can be lifted without damaging the subfloor, it's 5-year personal property under IRC §1245. If it's adhered, nailed, mortared, or structurally integrated, it's 39-year building property under IRC §1250.  ·  Finish material does not matter. Same carpet, same LVP, same hardwood — install method decides.  ·  Lighting rule: decorative + specialty = 5-year; general overhead = 39-year.  ·  Unknown install: default to 39-year (DepreciMax prompt-level rule, Nov 14, 2026).  ·  Bonus rate (2026): 100% permanent under OBBBA for qualified property placed in service after January 19, 2025.

Why install method matters: the §1245 vs §1250 distinction

The IRC splits depreciable real property into two broad classes. Section 1245 property is personal property — machinery, equipment, furniture, trade fixtures, and any improvement that is either (a) tangible personal property or (b) a structural component that qualifies as "other tangible property" used as an integral part of certain specified activities. Section 1250 property is the rest of the real property — the building and its structural components.

For flooring and lighting, the test that decides the recovery period is removability without damage to the structure. This is the framework the IRS Cost Segregation Audit Techniques Guide walks through in Chapter 7.2, and it's the framework the Tax Court applied in Morrison Inc. v. Comm'r (TCM 1986-129) when it addressed the §1245 vs §1250 classification of improvements that look structural but can in fact be lifted.

The removability test produces results that are often counterintuitive. Carpet — which most people think of as part of the finished building — lifts off a tack strip without damaging the subfloor, so it's personal property. A $45,000 glue-down vinyl floor — which most people think of as removable finish — has adhesive that cannot be separated from the subfloor without destroying the substrate, so it's a building component. The cost of the material is irrelevant. The finish-grade is irrelevant. Only the install method decides.

The flooring decision table

Below is the complete flooring classification table DepreciMax applies when reviewing listing photos and listing descriptions. Each row corresponds to a finish material + install method combination. DepreciMax defaults to the conservative classification when evidence of the install method is ambiguous (more on that below).

Finish material + install method Recovery period Bonus-eligible? Why
Carpet (any quality, any pad) 5-year Yes (100%) Secured at perimeter with tack strips. Lifts without damaging subfloor. Classic §1245 personal property.
Floating LVP (click-together, no adhesive) 5-year Yes (100%) Interlocking planks float on underlayment. No adhesive to the subfloor. Fully removable.
Click-lock engineered hardwood (floating install) 5-year Yes (100%) Same removability profile as floating LVP. The "engineered" construction is what allows the click-lock joint.
Sheet vinyl (loose-lay, no adhesive) 5-year Yes (100%) Loose-lay sheet vinyl tacks at perimeter only. Removable.
Glue-down LVP 39-year No Adhesive integrates with subfloor. Removing the plank destroys the substrate. §1250 structural component.
Nailed solid hardwood 39-year No Nail-down fastens plank to subfloor; nail-pattern density is structural integration. Not removable without destruction.
Nailed engineered hardwood 39-year No "Engineered" describes the plank construction, not the install. If it's nailed, it's structurally integrated.
Mortared ceramic tile 39-year No Thinset + grout are permanent. Tile cannot be lifted without destroying the tile and the cement board beneath.
Mortared porcelain tile 39-year No Same install profile as ceramic. Finish durability (porcelain vs ceramic) does not change the classification.
Mortared stone tile (travertine, marble, slate) 39-year No Same install profile as ceramic. Natural stone finish at $25–$50/SF is still a building component when mortared.
Grouted tile of any kind 39-year No The grout joint is the signal. If grout lines are visible between tiles, it's a mortared install — 39-year.
Polished concrete (when the slab IS the floor) 39-year No Polished concrete that doubles as the structural slab is the building itself. The polish treatment is a surface finish of a §1250 component.
Sheet vinyl (glued full-perimeter) 39-year No Full-perimeter adhesive makes it non-removable without substrate damage. Same logic as glue-down LVP.

Install method is sourced from the listing description, the listing photos (edge details, transitions, baseboard gaps), or the seller disclosure. Where the install method is not specified or visible, DepreciMax defaults to the 39-year classification per the conservative-estimate rule shipped November 14, 2026 — see the callout below.

If install method is unclear: default to 39-year

DepreciMax's prompt-level rule (shipped November 14, 2026): when a listing photo shows "hardwood" or "LVP" or "tile" but the install method cannot be determined from the image, the listing description, or the seller disclosure, the component is classified as 39-year. Aggressive assumptions are the single biggest failure mode of DIY cost segregation estimates — they inflate the pre-purchase Year-1 number and then fail at the formal engineered study, which produces a surprise downward adjustment the investor built the deal around. DepreciMax deliberately under-promises so the formal engineered study your CPA files from comes back with upside, not downside.

Reading install method from a listing photo

Install method is often more visible in listing photos than most buyers realize. Here are the signals DepreciMax looks for when the listing description doesn't spell it out:

When a photo shows wide-plank "hardwood" in the main living area of a 2000+ build, the base-rate assumption is that it's nailed solid hardwood or nailed engineered hardwood (the dominant install method for mid- and high-grade new-build residential) — which is 39-year. Floating click-lock is more common in 2020+ builds, rental-focused flips, and condos (where the HOA restricts noise through the floor). If the listing description says "LVP throughout" or "waterproof vinyl plank," and the build year is 2020+, the base-rate assumption flips to floating LVP (5-year). But the right call is to confirm with the seller rather than infer from style alone.

Free · 30 seconds
Check any STR's listing photos + land ratio — free
Enter the address. We'll return the county assessor land split, the listing photos we analyzed, and a free Year-1 range in seconds. $99 unlocks the itemized line-item report with flooring + lighting classified per the rules above.
No credit card. Returns listing + land ratio + free Year-1 range.

Lighting classification: the split-category rule

Lighting is the other interior category where DepreciMax has been rewriting its classification approach. The old approach bundled all interior lighting into a single consolidated line item (typically $12,000–$18,000 for an average STR). That is not how a formal engineered study treats lighting, and it obscured the classification math — some fixtures in the bundle are legitimately 5-year, some are legitimately 39-year, and the right answer depends on the fixture's role in the building. The November 14, 2026 prompt rewrite split "interior lighting" into three distinct categories, each classified on its own.

5-year decorative lighting + ceiling fans

The following fixtures qualify as 5-year personal property because they are decorative or specialty improvements, not part of the building's general electrical system. The 5-year treatment covers the fixture only — the in-wall Romex feeding the fixture remains 39-year.

5-year specialty electrical + smart home

Specialty electrical systems that serve a specific appliance or specialty function are 5-year personal property. The distinguishing feature: they would not be installed in a general-purpose dwelling unit and are tied to a §1245 asset or a specific aesthetic function.

39-year general building electrical

The following are part of the building's general electrical system under §1250 and are not bonus-eligible, regardless of finish quality:

Below is the lighting + electrical classification table as it now appears in a DepreciMax $99 Depreciation Report, with each category as a separate line item instead of one rolled-up bundle.

Line item category Recovery period Examples
Decorative lighting fixtures 5-year Pendants, chandeliers, designer sconces, track lighting, under-cabinet LED, decorative recessed cans
Ceiling fans 5-year Bedroom fans, great-room fans, outdoor-covered-area fans
Smart-home control 5-year Whole-home automation hub, keypads, smart thermostats, AV / structured wiring
HVAC mini-split heads 5-year Indoor mini-split cassettes (one per zone)
Dedicated §1245 circuits 5-year Hot-tub circuit, EV-charger circuit, wine-cooler circuit, outdoor-kitchen circuit
General building electrical 39-year Primary overhead lighting, in-wall Romex, service panel, standard outlets, bathroom exhaust wiring

Worked example: flooring on a $900k Pigeon Forge cabin

Take a 2,000 SF, $900,000 Pigeon Forge cabin with the following flooring mix — the composition is typical for mid- to high-grade cabins in this market:

Actual 5-year flooring total: $3,500. Just the bedroom carpet.

Now imagine the same 2,000 SF cabin had been flipped to floating LVP throughout — a common pattern in 2020+ STR flips where the operator prioritizes durability and fast replacement for rental wear-and-tear. At $10/SF installed for the LVP alone, that's a $20,000 line item. All 5-year. A $16,500 swing in 5-year basis — same cabin, same square footage, same purchase price, same aesthetic quality to a buyer's eye — purely from install method.

At a 37% marginal federal rate plus state tax, that $16,500 swing in Year-1 bonus-eligible basis is worth roughly $6,000 in Year-1 cash tax savings on the right side vs the wrong side of the install-method call. For a STR investor comparing two otherwise-identical candidate cabins across a Pigeon Forge weekend tour, this is the kind of lever that decides which property to bid on.

🔍

Confirm install method before you make an offer

DepreciMax's $99 Depreciation Report classifies flooring and lighting line-by-line from the listing photos and listing description, using the exact decision tables above. If the install method is unclear, we flag the conservative 39-year default so the engineered study doesn't come back with surprises.

Run a Property Report — $99 →

Why DepreciMax split lighting into multiple line items

The pre-November-2026 version of the DepreciMax Opus prompt instructed the AI to "output interior lighting as one consolidated line item." The intent was simplicity; the effect was lower defensibility. A single $15,000 "Interior Lighting" line didn't tell the CPA or the formal cost segregation engineer what was inside it: decorative pendants (5-year), ceiling fans (5-year), smart-home keypads (5-year), general overhead cans (39-year), and in-wall Romex (39-year) were all collapsed into one number with one recovery period.

A formal engineered cost segregation study itemizes these separately because that's how the IRS Cost Segregation ATG expects to see them. The engineer's deliverable is a classification-by-classification walk-through with distinct line items for each category, each cited to its IRS authority. When DepreciMax's pre-purchase estimate uses a single rolled-up line, the CPA ordering the formal study can't easily match the DepreciMax estimate against the engineered line items — and the estimate ends up looking either inflated (if the AI counted too much in the 5-year bucket) or deflated (if the AI counted too little).

The split-category rewrite shipped November 14, 2026 brings the DepreciMax output format into alignment with how formal studies present the same information:

The total dollar amount in the pre-purchase estimate stays roughly the same. What changes is defensibility: every line item now maps 1:1 to a corresponding line in the formal engineered study, so the CPA can walk through the comparison without reconciliation surprises.

What a $900k cabin's flooring reclassification looks like in dollars

On a typical $900k Smokies cabin at ~2,200 sqft with mixed flooring types, the install method split determines your 5-year basis:

Scenario A — Floating/click-lock throughout (optimal):

Scenario B — Builder-default mixed install (typical):

Install-method swing on the same $900k cabin: $7,910 of 5-year basis = $7,910 Year-1 deduction difference, triggered entirely by install method. The finishes can be identical quality; the classification isn't.

DepreciMax's Nov 2026 prompt rewrite defaults unknown install method to 39-year because the aggressive assumption fails the engineered study. If the listing explicitly states "floating" or "click-lock", we reclassify to 5-year.

Screening tip: what to look for in listing photos

A five-minute photo scan before scheduling a showing can save a trip. The screening heuristics:

Pricing

From one property to your whole search

Single Report
$99
one-time · 1 report
Most Popular
Search Pack
$299
one-time · 10 reports
Membership
$249/mo
unlimited · guide included
For Firms
Custom
teams & brokerages
Compare all tiers on the pricing page →

Frequently asked questions

Is LVP flooring 5-year or 39-year property for bonus depreciation?

It depends on install method. Floating (click-together) LVP installed without adhesive qualifies as 5-year personal property under IRC §1245 because it can be lifted without damaging the subfloor. Glue-down LVP is 39-year structural property under §1250 because the adhesive integrates it with the subfloor. Same material, same brand, same thickness — the installer's method decides the recovery period.

Is hardwood flooring eligible for bonus depreciation in a short-term rental?

Click-lock engineered hardwood installed as a floating floor is 5-year personal property and is bonus-eligible. Nailed solid hardwood and nailed engineered hardwood are 39-year structural property and are not bonus-eligible. The nail-down method physically integrates the plank with the subfloor, which fails the removability test under the IRS Cost Segregation ATG and Morrison Inc. v. Comm'r.

Why is carpet always 5-year property?

Carpet is installed over a pad and secured with tack strips at the perimeter — it lifts without damaging the subfloor. That meets the IRC §1245 removability test for personal property. Carpet is one of the few flooring materials where the install method is the same across all installations, which is why it reliably classifies as 5-year regardless of quality or price.

Is tile flooring bonus-eligible?

No. Ceramic, porcelain, and stone tile installed with thinset mortar and grout is permanently integrated with the subfloor — grout and thinset are not removable without destroying both the tile and the substrate. That makes tile 39-year structural property under IRC §1250, consistent with the IRS Cost Segregation ATG's treatment of permanent floor coverings.

Can decorative lighting fixtures be bonus depreciated?

Yes. Pendants, chandeliers, designer sconces, decorative recessed cans, ceiling fans, track lighting, under-cabinet LED, and dimmer-controlled scene lighting are 5-year personal property because they are decorative improvements, not building-structure components. The 5-year classification covers the fixture itself — the in-wall Romex feeding it remains 39-year structural wiring.

Is general overhead lighting 5-year or 39-year?

39-year. Standard overhead lighting that serves as the room's main light source — builder-grade recessed cans in hallways, bedrooms, utility rooms — is treated as part of the building's general electrical system under IRC §1250. The 5-year decorative-lighting classification applies only to fixtures installed primarily for aesthetic or specialty purposes.

How does DepreciMax classify flooring when the install method isn't visible in the photos?

DepreciMax defaults unknown install methods to 39-year. This matches the prompt-level rule shipped November 14, 2026, and mirrors how a formal engineered cost segregation study handles ambiguous evidence — aggressive assumptions fail at the engineer-signed study stage, so we build them out of the pre-purchase estimate. If the listing description or a clear photo confirms a floating or click-lock install, the component is reclassified to 5-year.

Why did DepreciMax split lighting into multiple line items instead of one bundle?

The November 2026 prompt rewrite broke the old consolidated "Interior Lighting" line into separate categories because that's how a formal engineered study itemizes the deliverable: decorative fixtures separate from ceiling fans, separate from smart-home control systems, separate from HVAC mini-splits, separate from dedicated §1245 circuits. One rolled-up line obscures the classification math and makes the pre-purchase estimate harder to defend at the engineered-study stage.

Run any address before you make an offer

DepreciMax's $99 Depreciation Report classifies flooring and lighting from the listing photos line-by-line, using the exact decision tables in this article. Unknown install methods default to 39-year, so your formal engineered study doesn't come back with a downside surprise.

Run a Property Report — $99 →
Sources & Disclaimers

Federal authority: IRC §§1245 and 1250 (classification of personal vs real property). IRC §168(k), as amended by the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (P.L. 119-21) restoring 100% bonus depreciation for property acquired and placed in service after January 19, 2025. Classification framework: IRS Cost Segregation Audit Techniques Guide, Chapter 7.2 (property classification examples and removability test). Rev. Proc. 87-56 (class lives and recovery periods for depreciable property). Case law: Morrison Inc. v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo 1986-129 (install-method analysis of improvements that appear structural but are removable). Prompt-level rule: DepreciMax internal classification prompt, version shipped November 14, 2026 — unknown-install default to 39-year; split-category lighting line items replacing the pre-Nov 2026 consolidated "Interior Lighting" line. Nothing in this article is tax advice. Install-method classification is fact-specific; consult a CPA who specializes in short-term rental cost segregation before filing a return based on these rules. DepreciMax estimates are a pre-purchase screening tool, not tax advice. Consult your CPA before filing or making investment decisions based on these estimates.