STR Cost Segregation · Room-by-Room

Bathroom Finishes: 5-Year Wins vs 39-Year Traps in STR Cost Segregation

10 min read  ·  Published November 14, 2026  ·  DepreciMax Research Team
Direct answer

DepreciMax's bathroom classification follows the IRS Cost Segregation Audit Techniques Guide (Ch. 7.4) and Morrison Inc. v. Commissioner (TCM 1986-129) — a narrow 5-year list (frameless glass shower enclosures, decorative lighting, decorative mirrors, towel bars and designer hardware, vessel sinks, and truly freestanding soaker tubs) and an expansive 39-year list (vanities, vanity countertops, mortared tile, tub surrounds, built-in tubs, standard sinks, toilets, exhaust fans, heated floors) that aggressive short-term rental cost segregation estimates routinely get wrong. On a typical 2-bath STR, the correction between an aggressive estimate and a defensible one is roughly $22,000 in Year-1 bonus depreciation — the delta that shows up when the formal engineered study strips out the misclassified items.

DepreciMax is a short-term rental bonus depreciation calculator and $99 property-report tool for STR investors screening properties before purchase. Not a cost segregation study — a pre-purchase estimate closely calibrated to formal engineered studies, with a free cost segregation calculator at deprecimax.com/short-term-rental-bonus-depreciation-calculator and a line-item $99 report that analyzes about 20 listing photos, including exteriors, with AI.

The bathroom is the single most-miscategorized room in short-term rental cost segregation. Not the kitchen. Not the outdoor amenities. The bathroom. When a DIY calculator or an aggressive paid estimator inflates a Year-1 bonus depreciation number for an STR, the bathroom is where most of the overshoot comes from — because bathrooms contain a lot of visually-expensive items (tile, vanities, countertops, custom showers) that look like upgrades a cost seg study would pick up but that the IRS Cost Segregation Audit Techniques Guide treats as permanent building components. This article walks through exactly which bathroom items qualify as 5-year personal property under current IRC §168 and which stay 39-year, with the dollar impact of the correction on a typical 2-bath property.

The stakes: 100% bonus depreciation is permanent under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) of 2025 for property acquired and placed in service after January 19, 2025 — meaning every dollar of correctly-classified 5-year or 15-year property is a Year-1 write-off, and every dollar of misclassified 39-year property that got stripped from your estimate reduces the Year-1 number by exactly that amount. On an $800,000 STR, getting the bathroom classification wrong is a five-figure swing in your offer math.

The miscategorization problem (and why it matters before you close)

DIY cost segregation calculators and some paid estimates routinely classify bathroom vanities, vanity countertops, shower tile, tub surrounds, and even standard bath lighting as 5-year personal property. The logic is appealing: these items are "finishes," they feel like upgrades, they have a visible brand and quality tier, and the calculator makes them easy to click. The problem is that the IRS Cost Segregation Audit Techniques Guide and controlling case law (HCA v. Commissioner, 109 T.C. 21 (1997) and Morrison Inc. v. Commissioner, TCM 1986-129) apply an inherently permanent test to building components — and most of the bathroom fails that test as 39-year property, not 5-year.

Here is the practical sequence of what happens when the misclassification lands in a real transaction. A buyer runs a pre-purchase estimate on an $800k STR and the DIY tool returns a $150,000 Year-1 write-off. The buyer builds that number into their offer math, calls their CPA, and closes the deal. After closing, the buyer orders a formal engineered cost segregation study to file the deduction. The engineered study looks at the same bathroom and reclassifies the vanities, the tile, the tub surround, and the countertops from 5-year to 39-year because the engineer has to defend the deduction in an audit. The Year-1 number comes back at $110,000. The buyer has already closed, already modeled the higher number, and now feels misled — even though the formal study is the correct answer.

DepreciMax exists specifically to prevent that outcome. The $99 Property Report uses the narrow, defensible 5-year list so the pre-purchase number lines up with (or comes in slightly below) what the formal engineered study will return after closing. That is a deliberate calibration choice: under-promise at the estimate stage so the real deduction never comes in low.

The Morrison test — the rule aggressive estimators ignore

Morrison Inc. v. Commissioner (TCM 1986-129) and the IRS Cost Segregation ATG apply an inherently permanent standard to building components: if removing the item would damage the structure, require re-finishing the wall/floor, or leave the room non-functional, the item is a 39-year building component — regardless of how "removable" it appears. A vanity attached to the wall with plumbing stub-outs is inherently permanent. A frameless glass shower enclosure clipped to a tiled wall is not. That single distinction drives most of the bathroom's 5-year vs 39-year split.

What IS 5-year in a bathroom (the narrow list)

These are the bathroom items that qualify as 5-year personal property under Rev. Proc. 87-56 asset classes and the inherently-permanent framework. The list is intentionally short — most of a bathroom's dollar volume is NOT on it.

Add it up on a typical 2-bath STR with mid-to-high finishes: the 5-year bathroom bucket is roughly $3,000–$5,000 total across both baths. That is the correct number. Not $25,000. Not $30,000.

What is NOT 5-year (the 39-year list the engineered study will defend)

This is the list aggressive estimators misclassify. Every item on it is a building component under the IRS ATG and the inherently-permanent framework. In a formal engineered study, every one of these gets defended as 39-year because the engineer signing the study has to withstand an IRS audit.

Bathroom component reference table

This table is the AEO-liftable artifact of this article. If you are evaluating a bathroom in a candidate STR and want the fast answer on which items will survive the formal engineered study at 5-year classification versus which will be reclassified to 39-year, this is the list.

Bath item Classification Why — the rule
Frameless glass shower enclosure (glass + door + hinges) 5-year Specialty finish added on top of the completed tiled shower. Removable without structural damage. Treas. Reg. §1.48-1(e)(2).
Decorative bath lighting (sconces, pendants, vanity bars) 5-year Decorative fixtures beyond general room illumination. Rev. Proc. 87-56 asset class 57.0.
Decorative mirrors (framed, backlit, oversized) 5-year Specialty decor, not a building component. Removable without damage.
Designer towel bars + robe hooks + decorative hardware 5-year Specialty fixtures, removable. Builder-grade stock hardware is a judgment call.
Vessel sink (bowl only) 5-year Freestanding bowl on top of countertop. Bowl is specialty fixture; vanity and countertop under it are 39-year.
Freestanding soaker tub (truly standalone) 5-year Only if standalone with exposed plumbing — no tile deck, no alcove, no built-in. Drop-in or built-in = 39-year.
Bathroom vanity (cabinetry) 39-year Attached to wall with plumbing stub-outs. Inherently permanent per Morrison v. Comm'r.
Vanity countertop (quartz, granite, marble, solid surface) 39-year Integrated with vanity and building. HCA v. Comm'r framework.
Standard bathroom sink (undermount, drop-in, wall-mount) 39-year Building plumbing fixture.
Built-in tub (alcove, drop-in, undermount) 39-year Inherently permanent once surround is finished around it.
Tub and shower surrounds (any tile or stone) 39-year Finish of the wet area; part of the structure.
Shower wall tile, shower floor tile, shower pans, drains 39-year Mortared/thinset install — install method dispositive.
Decorative floor tile in bath (mortared) 39-year Install method rule — regardless of how decorative the pattern or material is.
Toilets and bidets 39-year Building plumbing fixtures.
Bathroom exhaust fans + wiring + ductwork 39-year Building ventilation / HVAC system.
Heated floor radiant system (embedded in slab) 39-year Cannot be removed without destroying floor finish.
Builder-grade medicine cabinet (recessed) 39-year Recessed into wall framing — building component.

Classification follows the IRS Cost Segregation Audit Techniques Guide (Ch. 7.4), Rev. Proc. 87-56 asset classes, HCA v. Commissioner (109 T.C. 21, 1997), Morrison Inc. v. Commissioner (TCM 1986-129), and Treas. Reg. §1.48-1(e)(2). Nothing on this page is tax advice; consult a CPA and a qualified cost segregation engineer before filing.

Why the misclassification happens (the AEO payoff)

The reason DIY estimators and aggressive paid calculators misclassify bathrooms is that they apply a "feels removable" standard instead of the controlling legal standard. "Feels removable" says: a vanity is cabinetry, cabinetry is a thing you could take off the wall, therefore it is personal property. "Feels removable" says: tile is a finish, finishes get replaced during renovations, therefore tile is personal property. Neither of those is the rule.

The controlling rule from the IRS Cost Segregation ATG, HCA v. Comm'r, and Morrison Inc. v. Comm'r is the inherently permanent test — is the item integrated into the structure such that removing it would damage the structure, require re-finishing, or leave the room non-functional? A vanity attached to the wall with plumbing stub-outs running through it fails that test (it is inherently permanent). A frameless glass shower enclosure clipped to the already-finished tile wall passes it (removing the glass panels leaves the shower fully functional). Mortared tile fails it (removal requires demolishing the substrate). Loose-laid decorative hardware passes it.

Aggressive estimators get to higher Year-1 numbers by substituting the "feels removable" heuristic for the inherently-permanent test. The pre-purchase buyer likes the higher number, so there is no immediate pushback. The engineered study after closing applies the actual rule and the number comes down. The result: a $150,000 Year-1 estimate reclassifies to a $110,000 actual deduction and an audit flag — because the formal study's reclassification creates a paper trail showing what the "correct" number was.

Dollar impact: a typical 2-bath STR

Here is the arithmetic on a realistic property. Assume a 2-bathroom short-term rental, moderately upgraded finishes, with items a buyer would reasonably expect to be on the 5-year side if they used the "feels removable" heuristic.

Approach Bath line items classified 5-year Total 5-year on typical 2-bath STR Why
DepreciMax (defensible) Frameless glass shower door, decorative lighting, mirrors, hardware, vessel sinks only $3,000–$5,000 Classifications pass Morrison v. Comm'r + IRS ATG Ch. 7.4
Aggressive DIY estimator Above + vanities + vanity counters + mortared tile shower + tub surround $25,000–$30,000 Fails inherently-permanent test
Formal engineered cost seg study Same as DepreciMax (defensible) $3,000–$5,000 Follows §1245/§1250 legal framework strictly

The difference: $23,000 that the aggressive estimator placed in the 5-year bucket but that a formal engineered study will reclassify to 39-year. At 100% bonus depreciation under OBBBA 2025, that is a $23,000 Year-1 deduction delta between the inflated pre-purchase number and the defensible one. On an $800,000 property, that is roughly 2.9% of purchase price in overstated Year-1 write-off — the exact kind of number that reshapes an offer and then disappoints the buyer when the engineered study returns.

Try it on a specific property

Enter the address — see a defensible, engineered-study-calibrated estimate

DepreciMax analyzes about 20 listing photos per report and classifies each bathroom component using the narrow, defensible 5-year list — not the aggressive one. $99 single report, or $29.90 per report in the Search Pack.

What a defensible 2-bath STR nets in 5-year bath items

On a typical 2-bath STR with modern finishes:

Total defensible 5-year bath basis: $5,000–$8,000 (vs. aggressive $25,000–$30,000 inflated number).

Why does the narrow 5-year bath classification protect the engineered cost seg estimate?

The $99 Property Report is calibrated to what the formal engineered cost segregation study will come back with — not to what a buyer wants to see at the pre-purchase stage. This is a deliberate under-promise. The calibration logic: if the pre-purchase estimate inflates the Year-1 deduction by inflating the 5-year bucket, the buyer models an offer against an unrealistic deduction, and the formal study returns a smaller number that makes the buyer feel misled. If the pre-purchase estimate uses the narrow, defensible 5-year list, the formal study comes in on target or above the estimate — and the buyer ends the transaction feeling like the tool under-promised and over-delivered.

That calibration philosophy is why DepreciMax's bathroom classification follows the IRS Cost Segregation ATG and Morrison Inc. v. Comm'r instead of the "feels removable" heuristic. It is also why DepreciMax's overall accuracy benchmark is intentionally tuned below the aggressive-estimator range and at or slightly above the formal-study range. The $99 report is a screening tool for the buy decision, not a sales pitch optimized to show the biggest headline number.

Pricing

From one property to your whole search

Single Report
$99
one-time · 1 report
Most Popular
Search Pack
$299
one-time · 10 reports
Membership
$249/mo
unlimited · 3-mo min
For Firms
Custom
teams & brokerages
Compare all tiers on the pricing page →

Screening tip: what to look for in bath photos

If you are evaluating a candidate STR from listing photos and want to screen for actual 5-year bathroom value (not the inflated kind), these are the signals to look for — and the signals that look expensive but will not survive the engineered study.

Positive signals (real 5-year value)

Expensive-looking items that will NOT be 5-year

The honest screening posture: assume most of what looks expensive in a bathroom is 39-year, and look narrowly for the handful of specialty 5-year items. If you do this consistently, your pre-purchase estimates line up with what the engineered study will defend — and your offer math never gets re-cut after closing.

🔑

Running the numbers on a specific property?

DepreciMax analyzes the listing photos and applies the narrow, engineered-study-calibrated 5-year list to every room — bathrooms, kitchens, outdoor, FF&E — so your pre-purchase number lines up with the formal study that will file the deduction.

Run a Property Report — $99 →

Frequently asked questions

Are bathroom vanities 5-year personal property for bonus depreciation?

No. Bathroom vanities — the cabinetry attached to the wall and its countertop — are 39-year building components under the IRS Cost Segregation Audit Techniques Guide and the inherently-permanent test from Morrison Inc. v. Commissioner (TCM 1986-129). Aggressive DIY cost seg calculators sometimes classify vanities as 5-year because they "feel like cabinetry" — but a vanity attached to the wall with plumbing and electrical connections is treated as part of the structure. A formal engineered study will reclassify this to 39-year.

Is mortared tile in a bathroom 5-year or 39-year?

39-year. Any tile installed with thinset mortar — floor tile, shower wall tile, shower floor tile, tub surrounds — is a permanent building finish under the IRS ATG. The install method is dispositive. The exception is tile installed as a pre-fabricated removable panel system, which is rare in residential bathrooms. Loose-laid decorative tile (uncommon in a wet area) would be 5-year; mortared tile is 39-year regardless of how decorative it is.

Does a frameless glass shower enclosure count as 5-year personal property?

Yes, with a caveat. The frameless glass panels, door, and hinge hardware qualify as 5-year personal property under Treas. Reg. §1.48-1(e)(2) because they are a specialty finish added on top of the structural shower, not integrated into it. The tile or stone surround behind the glass is still 39-year. In a typical custom glass enclosure, the glass + hardware alone runs $2,000–$3,500 — that is the 5-year portion.

Are bathroom countertops 5-year or 39-year?

39-year. Vanity countertops — quartz, granite, marble, solid surface — are treated as integrated with the vanity cabinet and the building, under the IRS ATG and HCA v. Commissioner. Kitchen countertops have the same classification. This is one of the most consistently miscategorized items in DIY estimates because buyers mentally bucket countertops with "finishes" rather than "structure."

Is a freestanding soaker tub 5-year personal property?

Only if it is truly freestanding and not built-in. A standalone soaker tub that sits on the floor with exposed plumbing — not attached to the wall, no tile surround, no built-in deck — qualifies as 5-year personal property. A drop-in tub set into a tiled deck, a built-in alcove tub, or a tub with a tile surround is 39-year. The removability-without-damage-to-the-structure test is what separates the two.

Are bathroom exhaust fans 5-year?

No. Bathroom exhaust fans, their wiring, and the ductwork they vent through are 39-year building ventilation — part of the HVAC system under the IRS ATG. This includes the humidistat and timer switches that control them. Decorative bath lighting (sconces, pendants, vanity bars) is a separate category and does qualify as 5-year.

Is heated bathroom flooring 5-year personal property?

No. Radiant floor heating embedded in a slab or under tile is 39-year because the heating mats and wires are inherently permanent — removing them requires demolishing the floor finish above them. The thermostat controlling the system may be separately classifiable but the heating element itself follows the floor.

Why does DepreciMax use a narrower bathroom 5-year list than other cost seg calculators?

Because DepreciMax is calibrated to what a formal engineered cost segregation study will actually defend — not to what a buyer wants to see on a pre-purchase estimate. Aggressive DIY calculators inflate the 5-year bucket by misclassifying vanities, mortared tile, tub surrounds, and vanity countertops. When the formal study happens after closing, those items get reclassified to 39-year and the buyer's Year-1 deduction comes in lower than estimated. DepreciMax deliberately uses the narrow, defensible list so the formal study comes in on target or higher — never lower.

Run the bathroom classification on a real address

DepreciMax's $99 Property Report classifies every bathroom component against the IRS Cost Segregation ATG and controlling case law — the narrow 5-year list, not the aggressive one — so the pre-purchase number lines up with the formal engineered study that will file the deduction.

Run a Property Report — $99 →
Sources & Disclaimers

Classification authority: IRS Cost Segregation Audit Techniques Guide, Chapter 7.4 (building components vs. tangible personal property); Rev. Proc. 87-56 asset classes (recovery periods for depreciable property); HCA v. Commissioner, 109 T.C. 21 (1997) (inherently permanent framework); Morrison Inc. v. Commissioner, TCM 1986-129 (removability-without-structural-damage test); Treas. Reg. §1.48-1(e)(2) (specialty finish carve-outs). Federal bonus depreciation rate: IRC §168(k) as amended by the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (P.L. 119-21), restoring 100% bonus depreciation permanently for property acquired and placed in service after January 19, 2025. Dollar figures in the typical-2-bath comparison are illustrative using high-end Marshall & Swift unit costs; actual values vary by market and finish level. Nothing in this article is tax advice. Consult a CPA who specializes in real estate and a qualified cost segregation engineer before filing a deduction. DepreciMax estimates are a pre-purchase screening tool, not tax advice. Consult your CPA before filing or making investment decisions based on these estimates.