McCall, IdahoSTR Bonus Depreciation Market Profile · #31 in the DepreciMax Top 50

Why McCall ranks #31 for STR bonus depreciation

Strongest Diamond-density STR profile in the Northeast — a third of McCall short-term rentals hit ≥24% bonus-eligible % of purchase price. Cabin and lake-house amenity stack drives the 15-year improvement basis; state conformity state conformity reduces state-level benefit slightly, but federal Year 1 deduction is among the strongest on the list.

What drives McCall's high bonus depreciation?

McCall STRs lean heavily on the amenity categories the IRS classifies as 15-year land improvements: hot tubs, fire pits, outdoor kitchens, pergolas, and lake docks — all 100% bonus-eligible in Year 1 under §168(k). That amenity density pushes market-median bonus-eligible % to 23.7%, second only to Lake Cumberland KY (26.9%).

Does Idaho conform to federal §168(k) bonus depreciation?

Only partially. Idaho allows federal bonus depreciation to flow through, but adds back a portion at the state level and spreads it over a longer recovery period. The federal Year-1 deduction is unaffected — this is still a strong federal market — but the state portion of the savings is smaller than in fully-conforming states. PA-resident investors should model the state-federal split with their CPA before purchase.

Common bonus-eligible amenities in McCall STRs

Prevalence of 15-year land improvements we typically see across McCall short-term rentals — all 100% bonus-eligible in Year 1 under IRS §168(k):

McCall, ID vs Lake Cumberland, KY vs Driggs, ID — bonus depreciation comparison

The three markets share a similar bonus-eligible % profile in the DepreciMax Top 50 — the differentiation is rank, price point, and state §168(k) conformity.

Deeper comparative reading: Smoky Mountains vs. Blue Ridge vs. McCall: STR bonus depreciation showdown.

McCall bonus depreciation calculator (by zip code)

McCall spans 4 primary sub-markets with materially different STR economics. The calculator below has a zip dropdown — switch it to your area. The bonus-eligible percentage (McCall's market-typical 23.7%) stays constant across zips because it reflects the property type, not the location. state conformity — federal deduction is the primary benefit.

McCall zip code comparison

Looking for a deeper read on your specific property, not just the market median? Run the $99 McCall property report — our AI analyzes 7–9 listing photos against the IRS classification rules and returns a line-item §168(k) estimate closely calibrated to a formal $5K–$8K cost seg study.

Representative listings & deductions

Three live McCall listings spanning entry, mid, and high price tiers. Year 1 deduction is estimated as a range around the McCall market bonus-eligible average (23.7% ± 3 percentage points). Click any card to run a full property report to tighten to one exact number.

Entry — McCall, ID

$837,500

Typical STR-suitable listing

McCall Village, ID 83638

Est. Year 1 Deduction

$178k–$218k

~$66k–$80k federal savings @ 37%

Get DepreciMax Breakdown On This Property →

Mid — McCall, ID

$1,274,500

Typical STR-suitable listing

McCall Village, ID 83638

Est. Year 1 Deduction

$271k–$332k

~$100k–$122k federal savings @ 37%

Get DepreciMax Breakdown On This Property →

High — McCall, ID

$2,423,000

Typical STR-suitable listing

McCall Village, ID 83638

Est. Year 1 Deduction

$516k–$631k

~$191k–$233k federal savings @ 37%

Get DepreciMax Breakdown On This Property →

How to use this data to underwrite a McCall STR deal

The market-median numbers on this page are a screening tool, not a final answer. Here's how STR investors and their CPAs actually convert a market rank + median bonus-eligible % into an underwriting number for a specific offer.

1. Screen the deal against the market median. If a McCall listing is priced within the p25–p75 range ($512k–$1,010k) and looks like a typical cabin or lake-house STR, the market-median 23.7% bonus-eligible is a defensible screening estimate. That gives you a Year-1 deduction range you can plug into an initial underwriting model in about 60 seconds — before you invest CPA time or offer-drafting effort.
2. Adjust up or down based on amenity signals. McCall properties with a full outdoor stack (hot tub + fire pit + wraparound deck + outdoor kitchen + pergola) trend toward the Diamond tier at 24–30% bonus-eligible. Properties with minimal outdoor amenities — condos, indoor-only cabins, or properties without lake access — trend toward the Bronze tier at 18–20%. Use the amenity checklist to categorize before you commit.
3. Model the offer with the deduction baked in. Take the estimated Year-1 deduction × your federal marginal rate (typically 37% for high-earner STR investors) = federal tax savings. Add this to your effective Year-1 cash-on-cash return. On a $1.27M McCall STR at 23.7% bonus-eligible, that's ~$112k in federal savings — often 8–12% of purchase price flowing back into Year-1 cash. Idaho's partial conformity means state-level savings are minimal for PA residents, so pure-federal math dominates.
4. Verify with a $99 property-level report before you sign. Once you're past screening and preparing to make an offer, run the specific property through DepreciMax's photo-analysis pipeline. The $99 report tightens the estimate to a single number, line-items the 5-year / 15-year / 39-year breakdown, and delivers a calibrated Year-1 number closely calibrated to a formal cost segregation study's bonus-eligible %. Your CPA can build the return directly from this output; a formal engineered study (typically $5,000–$8,000) is only necessary post-closing for IRS-defensible filing on very large deductions or high-scrutiny audit risk.

For further reading on the pre-offer bonus-depreciation workflow, see how to use §168(k) before closing on a short-term rental. To catch missed prior-year bonus depreciation using Form 3115, see the Form 3115 catch-up guide.